Introduction

Editorial Review

Author One-on-One: Curtis Sittenfeld and Emily Jeanne Miller

Curtis Sittenfeld: I love Brand New Human Being, and I also think it's a hard book to describe, plot-wise. When people ask what your novel is about, what do you say?
Emily Jeanne Miller: I've had a hard time with this, too--my "elevator speech." A writer-friend who read an early draft described it as the story of a man going from being a son to being a father, and I liked that. I liked it so much, in fact, I've said it a couple of hundred times since.

Sittenfeld: The setting of the novel is an unnamed town in Montana that you make vivid both through physical descriptions and with a storyline about environmental problems tied to mining. Did you have a specific place in mind, or is the town fictitious?
Miller: I lived in Missoula, Montana, while I was getting a Master's degree in Environmental Studies, and I also started writing fiction there. I don't know if it was the time in my life, or the work I was doing, or the stunning natural beauty that was all around, but the place really captured my imagination. That said, the city is fictional, and so are most of the other places I describe (as anyone who knows Missoula, or Montana, will quickly discover). The same is true with the mining case in the novel: the environmental issues are real, but the case and the facts I describe are not.

Sittenfeld: It seems to me that the idea of authenticity is especially prized in relation to the American West. Because you grew up and now live in Washington, D.C., do you feel worried about being considered an outsider looking in?
Miller: Sure--but only because I worry about everything! But really, no. Isn't being an outsider looking in what being a writer always is, to a certain extent? I know there are people who believe only person X can write a story about Y, but I'm not one of those. I think people can--and should--write about what they want to write about. Everyone has a unique voice, and thus something unique to add. Besides, this book isn't about the place (which is why I fictionalized the city, going back to your question above), it's about people--and I do have impeccable credentials when it comes to being one of those.

Sittenfeld: I know that when your agent submitted this novel to publishers, she did so under the name "E.J. Miller," and because your protagonist, Logan Pyle, is male, everyone assumed you were a man. What made you decide to write from a man's point of view? Have you had any male readers says Logan does things a man wouldn't? (I was totally convinced by him, but then again, I'm just a woman with a man's name!)
Miller: This question reminds me of a conversation you and I had, many years ago, about writing. Regarding a story you'd written, you said that in your secret heart, you were a cranky twenty-three-year-old woman. I laughed, and said in my secret heart I was a lonely thirty-five-year old man. I don't know if or why I really am that man, but I wrote this book from Logan's point of view because it just seemed clear to me that it was his story to tell. For a long time I was writing it in the third person, but then one day, for no reason I can recall, I started writing in his voice, in the first person, and something clicked. His story unfolded more naturally that way. I'm pleased to say that so far, people--men and women alike--seem very convinced by the voice.

Sittenfeld: I first met Logan Pyle ten years ago, when you wrote a short story about him. What made you know his particular story could or should expand into a novel?
Miller: I once heard a writer say that only failed short stories can become novels, and I think she was right. Brand New Human Being began as a failed short story that continued, through many rewrites and expansions, and over about a decade, to fail. The thing about this story (as opposed to other short stories I've written that didn't work) was that I couldn't seem to put it down for good. It felt like unfinished business, and stayed with me in a nagging way that kept me coming back until one day, distraught over shelving another novel I'd been working on, I went back to him once more. This time, I found there was lots more say. While I wouldn't necessarily recommend the ten-year gestation period to aspiring novel writers, I will say it paid off for me, in that by the time I sat down that last time, I already had the novel's basic frame--the setting, the main characters, and several plots, each with a beginning, a middle and an end. Of course there was still plenty left to figure out, and plenty that changed and surprised me over the course of writing the book, but I did feel I had a running start.

Sittenfeld: You and I are second-generation friends--not only are we close, but so are our dads, who went to college together and like to gossip on the phone. Will it be your dad who calls mine first after reading this interview or mine who calls yours?
Miller: Hmm, that's a tough one. They both know their way around a Google Alert, and are a quick draw with the phone. If I were betting, I think I’d have to hedge.

---

Excerpt

No Excerpt Currently Available

Discussion Questions

1. The author begins this novel with the lines, “My name is Logan Pyle. My father is dead, my wife is indifferent, and my son is strange. I’m thirty-six years old. My life is nothing like I thought it would be.” How did this opening prime you as a reader for what was to come? Why do you think the author decided to start with such a direct introduction?



2. The author, Emily Jeanne Miller, submitted this book under the name “E. J. Miller,” and publishers assumed it was written by a man. As a reader, would you have approached the novel differently had you thought it was written by a man? Why or why not?



3. In the opening chapter, what are some of the techniques the author employs to establish Logan Pyle’s mood and outlook on life? Give some examples that hit home with you.



4. Logan finds out that his wife and her boss—his father’s old best friend—have been plotting to dig up his father’s body for a case. How did he react when he finds this out through his wife’s boss instead of his wife? How do you think you would have reacted in the same situation?



5. Prior to their road trip, who do you think Owen is closer to: his mom or his dad? Explain your opinion and give examples.



6. After Logan and Julie make love for the first time in the book, on page 100, Logan leaves the bedroom and returns to find his son in his place. How does this make Logan feel? Does it reinforce feelings Logan has been having about Owen? Discuss your answer.



7. Vincent Vargas’s son, Doug, is the self-described “black sheep” of his family. When he reveals his opinion of Bennie, how does it affect Logan’s opinion of his young stepmother?



8. On Thanksgiving Day, Owen and the other kids at the party are watching The Empire Strikes Back when Logan peeks in on them—specifically the scene toward the end of the movie when Darth Vader tries to convince Luke to join him. (Page 115) What significance or symbolism does this scene have for this book?



9. Why do you think the author decided to narrate this book from a male perspective? Did Logan’s role as a stay-at-home “Mr. Mom” help with this point of view? How would the book have been different had it been written from a mother’s perspective?



10. Do you believe Logan makes the right choice when he takes Owen on a spontaneous road trip? What are some of the factors that motivate him to do so?



11. What memory does Logan conjure up about the night of his father’s funeral, on page 179? Do you view his character differently after learning about his encounter with his widowed stepmother?



12. When Logan and Julie talk by phone after he and Owen leave, with whom do you find yourself empathizing the most? Explain your opinion using examples from the novel.



13. After Owen’s near-fatal accident on page 218, did Logan react the way you expected him to? Why do you think he seemed to go from devotion to abandonment?



14. On page 237, the narrator asks, “Why are doors so much harder to open than they are to close?” Do you agree with Logan, that doors seem to be easier to close than to open? Why or why not?



15. When giving his final decision to Stan about the unearthing of his father, Logan says, “Someone did die. I guess I just took a while to understand that it wasn’t me.” (Page 252) What prompts Logan to admit this to the old family friend?



16. What was your reaction to Logan’s discovery in the last scene of the novel? Discuss the book’s ending and how you think the story will continue beyond the ending of the novel.



17. In an interview, the author described this book as a story about a man going from being a son to being a father. Do you find that to be an accurate description of the novel’s main theme? How you would describe Brand New Human Being to a friend who has not read it?

From the publisher

Weblinks

»	Publisher's Book Info
»	Author Emily Jeanne Miller's web site With contact info

Book Club Recommendations

Recommended to book clubs by 0 of 0 members.

Member Reviews

There are no user reviews at this time.
Rate this book