BKMT READING GUIDES

Silent in the Sanctuary
by Deanna Raybourn

Published: 2008-01-01
Paperback : 552 pages
1 member reading this now
0 club reading this now
1 member has read this book
Fresh from a six-month sojourn in Italy, Lady Julia returns home to Sussex to find her father's estate crowded with family and friends— but dark deeds are afoot at the deconsecrated abbey, and a murderer roams the ancient cloisters. Much to her surprise, the one man she had hoped to forget—the ...
No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to

Introduction

Fresh from a six-month sojourn in Italy, Lady Julia returns home to Sussex to find her father's estate crowded with family and friends— but dark deeds are afoot at the deconsecrated abbey, and a murderer roams the ancient cloisters. Much to her surprise, the one man she had hoped to forget—the enigmatic and compelling Nicholas Brisbane—is among her father's houseguests… and he is not alone. Not to be outdone, Julia shows him that two can play at flirtation and promptly introduces him to her devoted, younger, titled Italian count. But the homecoming celebrations quickly take a ghastly turn when one of the guests is found brutally murdered in the chapel, and a member of Lady Julia's own family confesses to the crime. Certain of her cousin's innocence, Lady Julia resumes her unlikely and deliciously intriguing partnership with Nicholas Brisbane, setting out to unravel a tangle of deceit before the killer can strike again. When a sudden snowstorm blankets the abbey like a shroud, it falls to Lady Julia and Nicholas Brisbane to answer the shriek of murder most foul.

Editorial Review

No editorial review at this time.

Excerpt

Lady Julia Grey has enjoyed her six-month sojourn in Italy immensely. But now her father is demanding that she and her brothers come home to England for the Christmas holiday. The thought of her home land is appealing, but can Lady Julia return to the scene of so much heartache? ... view entire excerpt...

Discussion Questions

1. Deanna Raybourn has an amazing gift when it comes to creating unusual and imaginative characters. Discuss your favorite character and explain what it is about him or her that captured your attention.

2. The relationship between Lady Julia Grey and Nicholas Brisbane is unconventional by Victorian standards. What are their long term prospects for happiness? Will society allow them to succeed?

3. The relationship between sisters is an important one, and most sisters would agree that their feelings toward one another can go from loving kindness to plain old nastiness in a matter of moments. Does this accurately summarize the relationships between Julia and Portia – and Emma and Lucy? Discuss their sisterly behavior and the reasons behind it.

4. Nature or nurture? Emma and Lucy were raised poor on the fringes of the wealthy, noble March family. How has this perspective shaped their characters? Would they have been different people had they enjoyed a more privileged life?

5. A reversal of fortune can have important repercussions on a person’s character. Discuss the ways in which Lucy, Ludlow, Sir Cedric, and Lucian Snow changed as a result of their revised circumstances. Were these changes positive?

6. Alessandro Fornacci offers Julia a different life than the one she is currently leading. What do you think originally attracted Alessandro to Julia? Could she be happy accepting his proposal?

7. The relationship between Julia and Morag is colorful to say the very least. Which of the two women is the more conventional? Discuss why. Could or should Julia replace Morag with someone else?

8. The story of Mariah Young gives the reader greater insight into Nicholas Brisbane’s early life. How has this relationship shaped his life?

9. Julia makes an unexpected, generous gift to Magda that some might describe as impulsive. Why did she do this? Was it the right thing to do?

10. Was there something about this story that took you by surprise? Discuss.

11. Titled, moneyed people of this time tended to remain inside their own social circle. It appears as if Lord March and Nicholas Brisbane ventured beyond the social bounds of the day. How do you describe the nature of the relationship between them?

12. Even for a family as unconventional as the Marches, the situations that played out in Silent in the Sanctuary are unusual. Would you agree that Lord March may finally want to settle into a more placid and quiet life? Did the events of this story take a toll on him?

13. Villains come in all shapes and sizes – and from all walks of life. Who among the various villains in Silent in the Sanctuary has the most for which to atone?

We hope this reading guide has enhanced your enjoyment of this wonderful novel. Deanna Raybourn's third book in the Lady Julia Grey series, Silent on the Moor, will be available in early 2009.

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

1. What is the central idea of the new book?

In Silent in the Sanctuary, I wanted to set the book in a classic English snowbound situation in which a murder happens and the house is full of suspects. I wanted to see if I could write it, because it’s a tricky thing to do – and I think I made it more so by having someone immediately confess to the crime. It poses then not one but two questions for the reader: Why was the person killed? And why did someone confess?

3. Tell us a little about the story:

The story opens with Julia and two of her brothers summoned home by their from a six-month spell in Italy. Joined by her brother Lysander’s new bride and an Italian bachelor with eyes only for Lady Julia, they arrive at the family home – a deconsecrated abbey in Sussex – to an estate brimming with houseguests.

Among the relatives and townspeople in attendance is the enigmatic Nicholas Brisbane with whom Julia collaborated in Silent in the Grave to solve her husband’s murder and with whom she had hoped to collaborate on something even more personal upon returning home … only to learn Brisbane has brought a fiancé to the festivities.

The homecoming takes an even more ghastly turn when one of the guests turns up dead, and the most unexpected of Julia’s relatives claims to have done the killing.

When a snowstorm shrouds the countryside in white, it falls to Lady Julia and Brisbane to sift through the clues – and the guests – before murder comes again to the isolated abbey.

4. What do you want readers to take away with them after reading the book?

I have a two-fold objective: I want them to have had a wonderful time, and I want them to be absolutely incensed that they don’t have their hands already on the next book. I hope they will love – as I do – the nice, twisty plot. I get it just where I want it, and then I twist the screw again. It’s much more fun that way.

Author Q&A:

Q. What kind of books do you write?

A. Historical fiction with a mystery slant. I say this because I hate to trot out the word “romance,” which creates very specific expectations, and not be able to then fulfill that expectation. The same could be said for mystery fans. That said, I think a lot of romance and mystery readers will find something they’ll enjoy in my books.

Q. Do you do anything in particular to keep your reader turning pages?

A. One of the things I try to do – and it’s very, very cruel – is try to end chapters where the reader doesn’t want to put the book down. I like nothing better than getting an e-mail from a reader saying, “I staggered into work ‘cause I was up ‘til 4 a.m. – it’s your fault! You did it on purpose, didn’t you?” Yes, I did.

Q. How does Lady Julia change in this book?

A. In Sanctuary, Julia continues on with a lot of changes she was making in her life in the first book. She is coming into her own more as an independent, self-determined woman. She’s figuring out what she wants out of life.

Q. Is Julia based on you?

A. My books are hugely autobiographical. Everyone who knows me and reads the books, says: “‘Oh, my god, this is you talking on the page.” It’s not like I have a lot in common with Julia (on the surface): I’m not actually English aristocracy. I’m not wealthy. I’m not a widow (I actually have a very nice marriage to a very lovely man). But when you compare our perspective of the world, my world view is not that different. Julia’s default emotion is optimism, as is mine. She would prefer to look at the bright side and have a laugh, than linger under the duvet. She would rather get on with things. She likes adventure but appreciates the support and security of her family. I think her values are similar to mine: you treat people decently because it’s the right thing to do.

Q. What is the purpose of her large family?

A. I really wanted a large cast of characters who can pop in and out of each book. No one will be in all the books – except for Julia, Brisbane and Julia’s older sister Portia. Brisbane, because readers would literally kill me if he wasn’t. (You wouldn’t believe how much time my readers spend trying to figure out who would play Brisbane in a movie version of the book. I ask them, “Who should play Julia?” They couldn’t care less, because they all see themselves as Julia.)

As for Portia, I didn’t plan to have her in every book, but so far she has turned up in all three, including my next Lady Julia Grey novel, Silent in the Moor. She’s quite the bossy sister; she loves to manage everyone – and they let her.

And here’s a little trivia about the March family name: I wanted to be able to use “mad as a March hare,” and I did a little research and learned that it was not something Lewis Carroll invented for Alice in Wonderland but rather comes from a 13th century proverb. I realized it could have been about my Marches, and I loved that. Their heraldic badge is a hare.

My Marches are crazy, but they have a good solid name that has pleasant connotations to people who love literature.

That’s it! Thanks!

jmd

Book Club Recommendations

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
 
There are no user reviews at this time.
Rate this book
MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Book Club HQ to over 88,000+ book clubs and ready to welcome yours.

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search
FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...