The American Spirit at its best here! So well written. It gave me a heartfelt understanding of the times they lived in. Joe is a classic overcomer. It inspires us all. Everyone at our book club enjoyed this book...even the hardcore fiction-istas.

There were so many different responses from our various members that it's hard to qualify this book as a great success or a dismal failure. "Unique, Fascinating progression of characters, Thought-Provoking, Self-indulgent, Incomprehensible, Unrealistic characters, Flashes of brilliance, Beautifully expressed philosophies." Be ready for a mixed discussion!

This quality of literature comes about once in a generation! Genius descriptions of a gorgeous (sometimes bleak) setting and complicated characters. The story, though well known, is told so beautifully that you want to read on forever. As an audio-book it is particularly engrossing! Read this book even if you've read it a dozen times!

This book is unlike any memoir we've read. A brilliant young woman, disabled by TB, develops into an optimistic, acutely honest, richly creative woman. She takes chances, pursues dreams, loves fiercely despite odds against her. This character will stay with me.

Prepare to be left with questions. Detailed facts and logistics are left out in favor of the beautiful prose of Katharine's observations of the scenery, events and people who interested her. She died before she could write enough for us to know her fully. Not an autobiography. It's a memoir and a very satisfying, enlightening one!

I like a book with redemption. In this book the characters got what they deserved, by and large. It was a feel-good story where your underdog favorite comes out on top.