Member Profile
Name : | Kelly A. |
My Reviews
I wanted to start this many times but since I knew it was sad I hesitated. It was terrific and I cannot wait til the movie comes out. I enjoyed the characters thoroughly and even though you know it is a tragedy, you find yourself wishing it wouldn\\\'t end.
It is many a parent's dream - your 14 year old comes over and throws (literally of course because he is 14) a book your way. It is accompanied by the sentence 'You have just got to read this Mom.' Yep be still my beating heart.
And I wanted to finish it about the same time as he did but I have honed in my reading whereas he has other reading obligations. Somehow though on this one, he beat me. His 'careful Mom it is sad' was a warning from him but a prodding for me to finish.
This is an interesting topic in which to write about. You wake up everyday as someone else. You have all of your own memories but you have this person's body and life to lead as well as the memories you can access.
Here are a few issues I had with the story:
-The main character A did not follow through on one of the tragic people that A inhabited. (I am not sure if A is male or female -which I fully believe is intentional- but I refuse to refer to A as it.) I truly felt that A should have followed up to check on that person's well being after leaving that body for the next. I mean A checks email and such - a simple check into how they were doing in my mind was acceptable.
- The ending left me sad and unsatisfied. I wanted a definitive resolution but one was not at hand. I felt something should be wrapped up or at least alluded to.
-I felt sorry for Nathan in this as he truly felt victimized. I also felt he was the only who spoke out - who else would have felt what he had felt afterward and during.
-The love story. I applauded A's personal decision that no sex should happen because that was a private thing that should be remembered. I wanted a love story that was felt on both sides of the romance. I didn't believe it for a second on this one. Her side felt pulled and contrived whereas A's felt true and real.
All this considered, I did enjoy this book like the 14 year old told me I would. I enjoyed the writing style and the topic. I enjoyed the characters on the whole and their struggles. I will definitely be recommending this to others.
So I went to a YA fan event sponsored by a bookstore in our area. It was a great time. We got to meet so many authors - including Katherine Howe. She is well, just amazing to talk to.
Her book was really terrific. If there is a time period that has always intrigued me, it would be the late 1600s or early 1700s. Either Scotland in that time when there were clans and the issues surrounding that or the area surrounding the Salem Witch trials.
So I read this story that told two stories at the same time. One was regarding the trials and the young ladies that were in 2012. I was amazed to read this was based upon a group of girls who actually had this in NY in 2012. My scientific side wants to inquire as to what really was going on.
The thought that all these girls had this conversion disorder - all manifesting in different ways, was new to me. I am a nurse by profession but honestly, my passion is not in the psychiatric area. All things associated with that fascinates me. And that this actually occurred is even more fascinating.
I love the correlation between the two stories. That was a highlight for me. I felt that they truly did have many similar aspects to the stories.
The characters in the 2012 story were "normal" girls that one could easily see either themselves or their friends in. I saw many aspects of the personalities in my own at that age and my friends.
Overall a truly amazing book by a very gifted and talented writer. I cannot wait to read more by her!
Book Club HQ to over 88,000+ book clubs and ready to welcome yours.
Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more