Our Club was about 50-50 on whether they really "liked" the book as one of their favorites, but with us, those are the ones that create the best discussions. So as far as a recommendation for a great bookclub book that generates alot of good talk this would be a really good choice. This gave a different perspective about what happens to us when we die,and also made you really think of all the people you come in contact with intimately and just casually.