A book full of interesting places and people. A read full of suspense and you'll find yourself having a hard time leaving it!. I only gave it 4 stars because it was a little hard to get into but once i did i couldn't put it down!! great read for discussion.

You will instantly find love for all of the characters. You are immediately grounded from day 1 of reading this book. Suddenly all of your problems seem silly compared to these people. Amazing read. Something that I have already recommended to soo many people, thank you Khaled.

While I finished the book (it took me a long time) most of the club didn't. This was a book with great details and an amazing story line. It was for me hard to read and sometimes I was thrown off track easily but it was enjoyable none the less. I found the characters to be non relatable but definitely interesting. Author has a great way of leading to suspense- with his tone of writing you just get this feel that something unexpected is going to happen. I loved the book, I just would recommend it for solo reading

An amazing read for all ages. Great story filled with angst, adventure and love. I would recommend this novel to a book club of any age!

Just a lot of fluff, characters were not that interesting, story line was not very eventful.

I thought that this book was interesting, not my typical read. Somewhat historical fiction, very romantic and artistic.

I became addicted to this book in the first 5 pages. The idea of writing the story in the dog's perspective was brilliant there is no better way it could have been written. It was romantic, funny and an awe-inspiring outlook on life. I loved it and passed it on to my Mom all within 24 hours.

Overall I enjoyed this book very much. Having studied school shootings and followed the incidence in the past, I felt that this book did a good job of setting the facts straight and elaborating on potential causes. I feel as though the book was a little bit too drawn out, I felt like the author started to repeat himself and our group found it hard to keep track of all of the killer's friend's names; which made it harder to pay attention to the chapters on them.

This is a great novel. The story (whether or not it is true is not the issue) is one of great success and hardships. It is very interesting and depressing at the same time. Even thought its credibility is a question it is still a wonderful read either way.