Member Profile
| Name : | Lindsey S. |
My Reviews
This book inspired terrific discussion amongst the ladies in our group and our host created a beautiful Iranian meal to get us into the mood.
Anne created believable characters and when the traditional "who would you have play so and so" question came up...most of us could immediately say an actor/actress.
The struggles the characters faced, the cultures, the different perspectives were true to life (at least as much as a group of middle class, caucasian, women could see).
The only negative for our group came in chapter 9 when Anne took a different perspective and started referring to Bitsy and Brad as Jin Ho's mother and Jin Ho's father. It was difficult to read and difficult to understand who's perspective she was sharing. But other than that we loved the varieties of perspectives.
Our club found this book to be sweet but pretty stereotypical of a "ladies' group" kind of book. We didn't feel the characters were very believable or well developed and we found the story line to be predictable in a lot of places. Anita was our favorite character. The theme of community and our need for kindred spirits in the midst of life sparked some conversation...but we weren't wowed by the book...we found ourselves commenting on other books that we read that were like this one.
I enjoyed the book very much...i felt like i had gone on vacation and met some lovely new friends.
I really enjoyed this book. The switching back and forth in the beginning between eras was difficult at first, but the stories began to make sense in light of each other. I was so eager to reach the end and sad at the same time. It is a great read!
It was a cute book, with a few little twists here and there, but for the most part predictable. It was a light Christmas read for our club, one that we appreciated in this busy month of December!
It was a bit slow, but i loved hearing about the radio show in the living room and the crazy gospel singers. I think it provokes lots of questions about religion, family jobs, and small town life.
Rhodes has an incredible depth in his character creation, I am left wishing there were more pages to this already nearly 500 page book. The reality that relationships are anything but uniform, the thread of hope, the reminder of the freedom in forgiveness are only three of many topics that are tucked inside this text begging to be mined by book clubs everywhere.
It's sci-fi/mystical nature of the premise nearly turned me off in the beginning but like most 5th graders reading "A wrinkle in Time", I was quickly pulled into the chaos and enchanted by the era, mannerisms, the dichotomy of Courtney/Jane's character and all the hints of Ms. Austen. I was pleasantly surprised by the themes that emerged: forgiveness, regret, the journey to define happiness and contentment, the challenges of seeing beyond what is visible, and like most Austen books-pride. I thought it was fun, engaging, and clever. And I can only imagine the discussions about everyone's Austen fantasies that would emerge at a group discussion around this book!
It was an interesting twist to think of Marmee as an activist...I enjoyed the read. It was quick, insightful, and well written.
I thought Kate did a great job of explaining and sharing the ups and downs of meeting a long missing family member...she welcomed readers into the journey and I found the book to be thought provoking and beautifully written.
it was a great way to welcome in the holidays...and a glimpse into what post war england may have been like.
I didn't want to put it down...i was sad when it was over.
I loved the twists, the history, the glimpse into what it may have felt like to live in a world where bombs went off daily and life was hard but full of glamorous dreams. A second chance...who doesn't like a book with a good second chance?
Book Club HQ to over 88,000+ book clubs and ready to welcome yours.
Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
