Overall, our group really enjoyed the book. (Some guessed the ending right away and were sad there wasn't the usual dramatic twist at the end). Jodi really did her homework and gave great descriptions of what it's like to have Asperger's or live with someone who does. We discussed how we all need to be kinder to one another -- especially to those who are "different". Many felt badly for the "normal" brother, who was left to raise himself. Some parts were unrealistic (the mom turning her son in, having such an inexperienced lawyer, etc.) but the book moved along well and gave readers food-for-thought.

Engaging pre-civil war piece. The author keeps the reader intrigued by alternating the voice between two main characters (one a black slave and the other a white indentured servant). Themes of slavery, social status, survival, mental illness and family are explored.

We enjoyed the suspense....only a few guessed the killer before the end. Lots of twists and turns. Great debut!