Those who read Olive Kitteridge once with the understanding of following Olive and not worrying about individual characters loved the book second-most to those who read the book twice -- loved it with a passion, and got into heavy discussion. It was a story that everyone should be able to identify with on some level. It was a book club meeting that was longer than any other, and revealed more personal details about our own book club members, and more emotion, connection, and affection than any other meeting we have ever had. We've been a very strong book club (20+ members)for more than 7 years. There were 3 members who did not finish the book and/or didn't care for it. But after our discussion, those 3 decided to read it again/finish the book. This is truly a special book, though it is NOT one I would have chosen, nor one I would have continued to read after a few chapters if I didn't have to read it for Book Club. On the other hand, now that I have read it twice, I have to admit, I want to read it yet again, which is something I have NEVER done in my entire life.