actually 3.5 -4
If you like Bear and the Nightingale, you will like this...a very good sequel. the author does a good job of reminding you in the beginning, what took place in the first book, if its been a while since you read it...without making it feel like a rehash.
While Vasaya annoys me in the beginning, not listening , doing what she wants, etc. You really get drawn up in her character.
A good read unless you don't like fairy tales.