Once again Elin Hilderbrand visits Martha's Vineyard & Nantucket for this title. She paints both islands with her lyrical descriptions and fills them with interesting characters tangled in past relationships, old wounds, and new romances. The focus are adult twins who are divided by past mistakes and current missteps. A daughter and niece finds herself trying to grow up and understand her place amongst this fractured family. I found this read enjoyable as much for the settings as the characters and plot.

Harper and Tabitha are identical twins but could have more different personalities. Despite this they are inseparable growing up. All of that changes when they parents divorce and they are forced to chose which girl will live with which parent. That is the start of their estrangement. About a decade later, the girls are forced to face each other once again and face family secrets, lies and gossip.